TODAY Show Fashion Feud: Craig Melvin Defends Dylan Dreyer in Heated Socks vs. Stockings Debate

As the crisp autumn air swept through New York City, the hosts of NBC’s TODAY show took the opportunity to remind viewers to bundle up for the chilly season during their October 15 Third Hour segment. What started as a cozy, lighthearted discussion about fall fashion quickly escalated into a playful yet fiery debate, with co-anchors Dylan Dreyer and Sheinelle Jones locking horns over a classic cold-weather wardrobe choice: socks versus stockings. Caught in the middle, Craig Melvin stepped in as the unlikely mediator, passionately defending Dylan and playfully dubbing Sheinelle a “workplace bully” in a moment that left her stunned on live television.

The segment began innocently enough, with the TODAY team embracing the shift to fall weather in New York City, where temperatures have finally dipped, signaling the overdue arrival of autumn. Dylan Dreyer, 44, kicked off the conversation by mentioning a thoughtful gift from her co-anchor Craig Melvin, 46: a set of cozy socks for the team. When Craig asked if she was wearing them, Dylan revealed she had opted for stockings instead, citing the chilly weather as her reason. “It’s getting cold out there, and stockings just felt right today,” she explained with a smile, expecting a nod of agreement from her colleagues.

Enter Sheinelle Jones, who couldn’t resist a playful jab. With a mischievous grin, she quipped, “1987 called, and they want their stockings back!” The studio erupted in laughter, but Dylan’s expression hinted at mock offense, setting the stage for a spirited back-and-forth. Sheinelle, known for her quick wit, doubled down, teasing Dylan about her “outdated” fashion choice and suggesting socks were the superior, modern option for staying warm. Dylan, however, stood her ground, defending stockings as a timeless and practical choice for fall outfits, especially when paired with skirts or dresses.

Craig Melvin, sensing the escalating banter, jumped in to restore order, but not without adding his own flair. “Hold on, Sheinelle, you’re coming in hot with the bullying!” he exclaimed, pointing at her with a grin. “Dylan’s out here making a bold fashion statement, and you’re throwing shade like it’s a full-time job!” The accusation of “workplace bully” sent the studio into another round of laughter, with Sheinelle feigning shock, her jaw dropping as she clutched her chest dramatically. “Me? A bully? I’m just keeping it real!” she retorted, sparking more giggles among the trio.

Despite the teasing, the exchange remained quintessentially TODAY—animated, good-natured, and full of camaraderie. The hosts quickly laughed off the mock feud and transitioned back to the show’s signature blend of news and entertainment. However, the socks-versus-stockings debate highlighted the playful chemistry that makes the Third Hour a fan favorite, with each host bringing their unique personality to the table.

Meanwhile, absent from the segment was veteran meteorologist Al Roker, whose presence might have balanced the lively debate. Though he missed the on-air antics, Al was busy sharing his own cold-weather wisdom on the Start TODAY social media page. Addressing New Yorkers feeling the autumn chill, he advised against overbundling. “You don’t need coats as much as you think you do!” he declared, showcasing his signature practical yet stylish approach. “A nice, warm sweater or a heavier suit jacket does the trick. Add a scarf and a hat, and you’re good to go—unless it’s raining, then maybe a light jacket!” Al’s advice, paired with his sharp plaid brown suit and dark brown fedora, served as a masterclass in fall fashion.

As the TODAY team wrapped up their segment, the socks-versus-stockings debate left viewers with a smile and a reminder to embrace the season’s chill with style. Whether Team Dylan with her classic stockings or Team Sheinelle with her trendy socks, the hosts proved that even a wardrobe disagreement can spark joy on morning television. With Craig’s quick mediation and Al’s off-screen wisdom, the TODAY show once again delivered a mix of warmth, humor, and relatable moments, perfectly capturing the spirit of fall in New York City.